Skip to content

Functional vs Non-Functional Requirements

This section helps distinguish between functional and non-functional requirements to aid in the selection of an appropriate messaging system.

Functional Requirements

Functional requirements describe the specific behaviors, features, and functions a messaging system must provide. They are the foundational capabilities enabling the system to operate as intended. Key aspects include:

  • Message Delivery
  • Scenario: A retail platform ensuring orders are received and processed by fulfillment centers.

  • Key Questions: Are messages guaranteed to be delivered? What happens if delivery fails?

  • Supported Messaging Patterns

  • Scenario: A financial service using request-reply for transaction validations.

  • Key Questions: Which messaging patterns are crucial? Do they align with business processes?

  • Integration

  • Scenario: An IoT system connecting sensors to analytics platforms.

  • Key Questions: What protocols are necessary for seamless integration? Are there existing API dependencies?

  • Message Routing

  • Scenario: A media company distributing live sports feed to multiple outlets.

  • Key Questions: How are messages routed within the network? Is content-based filtering needed?

  • Persistence

  • Scenario: A critical alert system retaining messages until acknowledgment.

  • Key Questions: How long must messages be stored? What backup mechanisms exist?

  • Error Handling

  • Scenario: A logistics system retrying failed deliveries automatically.

  • Key Questions: Are retries automatic or manual? How are failures logged and reviewed?

  • User Authentication

  • Scenario: A secure messaging platform authorizing financial transactions.

  • Key Questions: What authentication methods are supported? Are there multi-factor options?

  • Monitoring and Logging

  • Scenario: A network provider tracking data transfer rates and message lags.

  • Key Questions: What metrics are tracked in real-time? How are logs accessed and analyzed?

  • Administration Tools

  • Scenario: An enterprise IT team managing access control policies and system alerts.
  • Key Questions: How intuitive are the management interfaces? What controls are available for admins?

Non-Functional Requirements

Non-functional requirements specify the quality attributes, performance, and constraints of the system, often defining how it achieves the intended functionality. They are critical for ensuring user satisfaction and operational efficiency:

  • Scalability
  • Metric: Ability to scale horizontally, supporting growth from 10,000 to 1 million users.
  • Benchmark: Kubernetes deployment achieving automatic scaling.

  • Decision Guide: Assess horizontal vs. vertical scaling based on expected growth.

  • Latency

  • Metric: Average message delay not exceeding 50ms.
  • Benchmark: Low-latency networks for high-frequency trading.

  • Decision Guide: Prioritize for real-time systems and adjust commitment accordingly.

  • Throughput

  • Metric: Capability to handle up to 1 million messages per second.
  • Benchmark: Stress test results under peak load conditions.

  • Decision Guide: Align with expected message volume during peak times.

  • Reliability

  • Metric: 99.999% success rate with failover mechanisms.
  • Benchmark: Dual data centers enabling active-active clustering.

  • Decision Guide: Implement failover strategies matching service continuity needs.

  • Availability

  • Metric: 99.99% uptime with automated recovery processes.
  • Benchmark: Real-world uptime SLAs from leading cloud providers.

  • Decision Guide: Evaluate single-region vs. multi-region deployments.

  • Durability

  • Metric: Data loss not exceeding 1 in 1 billion transactions.
  • Benchmark: Redundant storage solutions with automatic replication.

  • Decision Guide: Necessary for systems requiring permanent message storage.

  • Security

  • Metric: AES-256 encryption for all data transfers.
  • Benchmark: Compliance with ISO 27001/27017 standards.

  • Decision Guide: Mandated for industries dealing with sensitive data.

  • Maintainability

  • Metric: Ability to deploy updates with zero downtime.
  • Benchmark: Use of CI/CD pipelines for seamless integrations.

  • Decision Guide: Requires high reliability and frequent updates.

  • Portability

  • Metric: Deployment possible across AWS, Azure, and GCP.
  • Benchmark: Use of containers for consistent deployment experience.

  • Decision Guide: Considerations for multi-cloud strategy or hybrid environments.

  • Compliance

  • Metric: Complete alignment with regulatory standards like GDPR and HIPAA.
  • Benchmark: Regular compliance audits and certifications.

  • Decision Guide: Essential for legal and regulatory adherence.

  • Cost Constraints

  • Metric: Total cost under predetermined budget constraints.
  • Benchmark: Cost optimization strategies balancing quality and investment.
  • Decision Guide: Decision influenced heavily by operational budgets and cost-benefit analyses.